State Guide · Idaho Resident / New York Employer
Living in Idaho,
Working for a New York Company
Your tax situation changes significantly depending on whether you work from home or commute to New York. Here's exactly what applies to you.
⚠ Important: Convenience of Employer Rule
New York applies a "Convenience of Employer" rule. Even fully remote workers may owe New York taxes unless their employer required them to work remotely. This is one of the most aggressive state tax rules in the country.
🏠 If You Work From Home in Idaho (Fully Remote)
Withholding
Even working from home, New York taxes your income because your employer is based there. Your employer should withhold New York taxes — not Idaho taxes. Check your paystubs carefully.
Filing
File a nonresident return in New York AND a resident return in Idaho. Idaho will give you a credit for taxes paid to New York to reduce double taxation.
🏢 If You Commute to New York (In-Office)
Withholding
Your employer will typically withhold New York state taxes for days you physically work there.
Filing
File a Nonresident Return with New York to report income earned there. Then file a Resident Return in Idaho and claim a credit for taxes paid to New York — so you are not double-taxed.
Because tax situations — especially surrounding remote work — can be complex, verify your specific W-2 reporting by consulting a tax professional or your employer's HR payroll system.
Ready to file?
Multi-state returns can be complex. TurboTax handles both states in one workflow, or connect with a CPA who specializes in remote workers.
File Accurately — Recommended Tools
More Guides for Idaho Residents